Top 3 Underrated Netflix Shows with High Rotten Tomatoes Ratings (May 2026)

If you’re tired of mainstream hits on Netflix and looking for something a little more under-the-radar, you’ve come to the right place. This month, we’re highlighting three underrated shows on the platform that have surprising Rotten Tomatoes scores.

First up is “The Get Down,” a music drama created by Baz Luhrmann. Set in late ’70s New York City, it follows a group of young people in the South Bronx as they navigate the rise of hip-hop. Led by Justice Smith as orphaned teenager Zeke Figuero, the show brings together a stellar cast including Jaden Smith, Shameik Moore, and Jimmy Smits. Despite being canceled after just one season, “The Get Down” boasts an impressive 81 percent Rotten Tomatoes score and is a true work of art with its bold visuals and killer soundtrack.

Next, we have “Brand New Cherry Flavor,” which has a Rotten Tomatoes score of 76 percent. This show is set in 1990s Hollywood and follows aspiring filmmaker Lisa Nova, played by Rosa Salazar, as she navigates the cutthroat world of the movie industry. With a mix of horror and drama, “Brand New Cherry Flavor” offers a unique and engaging storyline that sets it apart from mainstream fare.

So, if you’re in the mood for something fresh and exciting on Netflix, give these underrated gems a try. You might just discover your next favorite show!