Dr Caroline Muirhead Update: Hopeful Progress After Netflix’s Should I Marry a Murderer
In Netflix’s recent true crime documentary, “Should I Marry A Murderer,” we learn about Dr. Caroline Muirhead’s harrowing experience with a potential killer. After a tough breakup, Caroline found love with gamekeeper Alexander ‘Sandy’ McKellar on Tinder. They quickly got engaged, but before tying the knot, Sandy confessed to Caroline that he had been involved in a hit-and-run with his brother in 2017.
The victim, Tony Parsons, tragically lost his life in the accident, and the truth about Sandy’s past was a shock to Caroline. The documentary follows Caroline’s journey as she grapples with the reality of her fiance’s dark secret and her role in bringing him to justice.
So, what is Caroline Muirhead up to now after the events of “Should I Marry a Murderer”? Following the traumatic experience, Caroline faced immense stress and guilt. She criticized the police for their treatment of her during the investigation, sharing that she felt unsupported and vulnerable throughout the process.
Today, Caroline has relocated to the Scottish coastline, where she lives a clean, sober lifestyle. She is focused on her mental health, regularly seeing a therapist, and has strengthened her bonds with family. Additionally, Caroline has found love again and introduced her new boyfriend at the end of the documentary.
While the documentary was a challenging experience for Caroline, revisiting the past has provided her with a sense of closure and hope for the future. However, the fear lingers as she has taken precautions to protect herself, installing security cameras at home.
Regarding her medical career, Caroline Muirhead’s registration status as a doctor has been impacted by the events surrounding the case. Records indicate that a Caroline Elizabeth Muirhead was unregistered for administrative reasons in March 2024. Despite the challenges she has faced, Caroline remains resilient and determined to move forward.
“Should I Marry A Murderer” is currently streaming on Netflix. For more updates on Netflix content and news, follow The Holy Church of Netflix on Facebook.


