Top 7 Surprising Streaming Titles in September 2025

Excitement is building around the arrival of 7 new titles in September 2025. With both new and returning shows and movies hitting streaming platforms like Disney+ and Netflix, there’s a lot to look forward to this month. Variety and The New York Times have highlighted some unexpected drops in popular franchises and surprise indie hits that are sure to get people talking by the watercooler. Given the sheer volume of premieres this month, the big question is, which one will you watch first?

Why These 7 September 2025 Picks Matter For Your Watchlist Right Now

Variety’s recent roundup on September 1, 2025, showcased more than 24 new streaming movies and shows, giving viewers plenty to choose from. The New York Times has also pointed out some surprise returns stirring up debates among fans on what to watch next. As platforms like Disney+, Netflix, and Amazon cram their schedules with premieres, the challenge now is to decide where to start your streaming journey.

The 7 Picks That Will Define Your Streaming Queue This September 2025
1 – Highest 2 Lowest: Why This Oddball Netflix Pick Could Break Conversation
Netflix’s latest quirky addition to the lineup is generating buzz for its clever tonal twist that critics are loving. It’s the kind of show that will have you picking sides – will it hit the mark or miss it completely?

2 – Marvel Zombies: Why A Franchise Spin-Off Feels Risky This Month
Marvel’s dive into the animated and genre-bending world with “Marvel Zombies” is raising eyebrows as a risky detour for the beloved brand. Fans are split on whether this will be a hit or miss, making it a perfect debate topic for your watch party.

3 – Only Murders In The Building (New Drop): What A Returning Hit Means For Disney+
The new season of “Only Murders In The Building” is set to hit Disney+ in September, pulling subscribers back into the world of mystery and comedy. If you enjoyed the first season, get ready for some weekly watercooler discussions.

4 – Lilo & Stitch (Streaming Addition): Why A Family Classic Reappears Now
For those looking for a family-friendly option, “Lilo & Stitch” is making a comeback on streaming platforms in September. It’s a nostalgia trip for some and a delightful introduction for others, perfect for a cozy family movie night.

5 – Friendship: The Unexpected Indie That Could Surprise Fans
Keep an eye out for this unexpected indie film that critics are raving about. Sometimes, the smaller titles end up being the big talkers, and this one might just be the sleeper hit of the month.

6 – Warfare: A Big-Concept Film That Tests Streaming’s Blockbuster Strategy
“Warfare” is making waves with its larger-than-life concept that challenges the traditional blockbuster model. If you’re craving some spectacle without the need for a theater ticket, this film might be just what you’re looking for.

7 – The Paper: A TV Week Pick That Could Turn Into A Must-Binge
Highlighted by The New York Times as a TV highlight of the week, “The Paper” is aiming to bring back appointment viewing for select shows. If you’re a fan of must-binge series, this one deserves a prime spot on your Sunday-night lineup.

This whirlwind of premieres in September 2025 is set to redefine your streaming habits. With a mix of surprises and fan favorites, it’s all about choosing the titles that spark conversations and keeping room for unexpected hits. So, which of these seven picks will you be streaming first this month?