Disney’s Top TV Show Based on True Horror Story

A new series has quickly become a favorite on Disney+ with viewers raving about its chilling real-life inspiration. Good American Family, which premiered on March 19, 2025, has shot to the number one spot on the streaming platform and continues to captivate audiences. Starring Ellen Pompeo, Mark Duplass, and Imogen Faith Reid, this eight-part Hulu drama delves into the strange and controversial story of Natalia Grace, a Ukrainian girl with a rare form of dwarfism who was adopted by an American family in 2010 when she was believed to be seven years old.

What unfolds in Good American Family is a psychological thriller that is truly stranger than fiction, drawing comparisons to the movie Orphan from 2009. After being returned by her first adoptive family, Natalia found herself living with Kristine and Michael Barnett, who raised concerns that she was not a child, but rather a dangerous adult posing as a child. Kristine Barnett made headlines when she accused Natalia of disturbing acts, which Natalia has denied. In a surprising turn of events, the Barnetts successfully had Natalia’s legal birth year changed from 2003 to 1989, declaring her an adult in Marion County, Indiana.

Despite the charges of neglect of a dependent being dropped in March 2023, the case sparked a media frenzy and left the public divided. The drama of Natalia’s story is now being brought to life in Good American Family, inviting viewers to dive deep into the mystery and form their own opinions. With shifting perspectives, eerie parallels to Orphan, and a story that seems too bizarre to be real, this true-crime thriller has everyone talking and questioning what to believe. The debate about Natalia’s age and identity continues to divide opinions, making Good American Family a must-watch series for those who love a compelling and thought-provoking storyline.