Ranking of Netflix’s Fear Street Films: Comparing ‘Prom Queen’ to the Trilogy

Netflix’s ‘Fear Street’ trilogy has taken audiences on a wild ride through decades of horror influences. But which film reigns supreme? Let’s break it down:

In third place, we have “Fear Street Part Three: 1666” (2021). Split into two parts, this film introduces a spooky tale set in colonial times to explain the witch’s curse that kicked off the original events. Some viewers found the historical segment a bit lacking in scares and felt that the film stumbled before hitting its stride in the second half, which revisits 1994 for a stronger and more satisfying conclusion.

Next up is “Fear Street: Prom Queen” (2025), a fresh take on the classic boy meets girl, accused of murder story. While it doesn’t quite match the original trilogy’s magic, this film stands out for its creative kills, snappy humor, and ’80s vibes. Lori Granger’s quest for the high school crown is a fun and freaky ride that delivers exactly what it promises.

Taking the second spot is “Fear Street Part One: 1994” (2021), embracing the late ’90s and ‘Scream’ era aesthetic. With a killer soundtrack, lovable teen characters, and some classic masked killers, it’s a nostalgic and entertaining entry that leaves fans wanting more. The film’s focus on a sweet lesbian romance and fun kills keeps the audience engaged, even if the cliffhanger ending leaves them hanging.

Topping the list is “Fear Street Part Two: 1978” (2021), a standalone slasher throwback that excels in delivering scares and suspense. Set at Camp Nightwing, this film pays homage to ’70s horror classics while offering a well-rounded and thrilling narrative. The stellar performances and intense sisterly dynamic take the scares to new heights, making this film a standout in the ‘Fear Street’ franchise.

While each film has its strengths and weaknesses, “Fear Street” as a whole is a fun and thrilling ride that horror fans won’t want to miss. So grab some popcorn, turn off the lights, and enjoy the spine-chilling journey through Shadyside.